Wednesday, February 16, 2011

Florida Governor Rick Scott rejects Tampa-Orlando high speed rail-AP-2 updates

.
Update 2/28/11, "High speed lawsuit coming as soon as Monday?" Orlando Sentinel, Central Florida Political Pulse, Tracy, Matthews
-------------------------------
Update, 2/21/11, Fla. Governor Rick Scott reaffirms he will not accept high speed rail.
-------------------------------
Update, 2/16/11, "A lost cause: The high-speed rail race." Washington Post editorial

2/16/11, "Gov. Scott scraps Tampa-Orlando high speed rail plan," AP, B. Farrington

"Gov. Rick Scott is canceling a proposed high-speed train line between Orlando and Tampa promoted by President Barack Obama, saying Wednesday it would cost Florida too much even with $2.4 billion in federal help.

Cost overruns could put Florida on the hook for another $3 billion and once completed, there's a good chance
  • ridership won't pay for the operating cost,
meaning the state would have to pump even more money into the line each year, Scott said.
  • "The truth is that this project would be far too costly to taxpayers and I believe the risk far outweighs the benefits," the Republican governor, who took office last month, said in a press release.
He also said if the project failed, the state would have to return the money to the federal government. Scott said he informed U.S. Transportation Secretary Ray LaHood of his decision earlier Wednesday.

"My background is in business, not politics. But you don't have to be an economics expert to understand that
  • if you spend more money than you take in, your business will fail," Scott said.
The project was important enough for lawmakers to call a special session in December 2009 solely to approve money for an Orlando-area commuter rail system that would connect with the high-speed rail. They acted with urgency because the project was needed
  • to attract stimulus money for the high-speed rail.
High-speed rail is one of Obama's priorities, and his latest budget proposal calls for $53 billion over the next six years for projects across the country. Florida also stood to benefit when Republican governors in Ohio and Wisconsin rejected high-speed rail projects.
Scott criticized Obama's spending plans when he announced Florida would reject the money, saying the president's most recent budget proposal would
  • increase the country's debt.
"Higher taxes and more government spending is a recipe for disaster. Government has become addicted to spending beyond its means and
--------------------------------------------
Governor Rick Scott was supported by the Tea Party. A group of ordinary citizens in the Tampa area worked hard in the past year or two to defeat high speed rail, which would have run largely empty if it had been built. Florida is filled with poor people and is experiencing a declining population. Its depressed housing market will not recover for decades if ever. ed.


via Lucianne.com

4 comments:

Matt said...

Its a lose to the future of the USA and Florida. Rock Scott is a jack ass and needs to be impeached. He is against the middle class. Look at his budget plan, it completely annihilates the middle class funding.

susan said...

I see it differently. It was a chance to save Florida. Many residents along with Rick Scott took the opportunity. I lived in Tampa for several years recently. I saw a state that has been strip mined by politicians. Basic standards are not being met. Over many years it has become a state for the rich and poor at the expense of the middle class. It remains to be seen if that can change, but more of the same could only make it worse. Many people worked to defeat high speed rail, it wasn't just Rick Scott. From what I saw living there, the train would have run practically empty if it had been built. Florida has problems a project like this doesn't begin to address. If anything, it would make them worse.

Unknown said...

sometimes leadership means saying yes when the bottom-line seems to say no.
So far as I can see, Scott is saying no to jobs, to infrastructure development, to cash flow to Florida. Did the public works of the 30's really create lasting works that everyone needed and that made economic sense? Sometimes yes, but mostly no. But a lot of people had a chance to survive until economic times got better. Ultimately, is Scott saying no for the right reasons?

susan said...

I agree public works projects can be good, and Florida is in desperate shape. As I mentioned I lived in Tampa for several years and could write for hours about how the state has been turned into a cesspool by politicians. Aside from everything else, the train would serve only a tiny part of the state and I believe its ridership would have been very small. Florida is filled with poor people, it has no industrial base. It felt more like a third world country to me. What money is spent there must recognize it's a geographically large state with many problems that can't be solved by a train between 2 non-descript towns. You may have heard that some people who win the lottery end up declaring bankruptcy. The billions of dollars Obama was offering were dollars that other people earned, that were taken from them in taxes. Spend some of them in Florida, yes, but not on a shuttle train and not billions.